High Court Annuls Overseas Marriage After Ruling 'Wife' a Bigamist

By July 5, 2020Library

In order to be divorced you obviously have to be validly married, and bigamy remains a surprisingly common occurrence. In one case, the High Court found that a couple’s overseas wedding did not render them husband and wife – because she was already married to someone else.

A British solicitor and a Philippines-born nurse went through a wedding ceremony in a hotel in her homeland. After they returned to England, they lived together as man and wife and had two children together. She worked in the NHS and became a British citizen. Following their separation, she petitioned for divorce. He, however, argued that their apparent marriage was bigamous and therefore a nullity.

The woman argued that their marriage met all the requirements of Filipino law and that they had treated it as valid throughout their relationship. His opposition to her divorce petition was, she claimed, an attempt to gain financial leverage over her. The ceremony she had been through with another man over 10 years previously was not a marriage but an informal celebration of their relationship. That man had abandoned her and moved to the USA, where he was recognised as single.

The Court noted that neither the woman nor the man had emerged from the dispute with much credit. She had always believed that her previous marriage was valid and he had adopted a manipulative and unattractive stance in asserting his willingness to accept a divorce so long as there were no financial consequences for him.

In dismissing the woman’s divorce petition and granting the man a decree of nullity, the Court found that her previous marriage to the other man was valid under Filipino law. She remained the other man’s wife on the date that she purported to marry the solicitor and their bigamous marriage was therefore void from the outset. The Court noted that, by virtue of the Legitimacy Act 1976, its ruling did not affect the legitimate status of the former couple’s children.

  • For every problem there has been on my case, John always has a Plan B.
    Chambers 2019
  • He is very approachable and explains everything as well.
    Chambers 2019
  • Works incredibly hard for clients, and builds up strong empathy with clients while remaining objective and discerning.
    Chambers & Partners 2017
  • John Randle is efficient, calm, approachable, and realistic.
    Legal 500 - 2014
  • I received excellent service from John Randle. I could not have got through my case without all his help and support over the last 2 years.
    Mrs M
  • I would heartily recommend your services…..in such a stressful circumstance, it was such a relief to have someone of your calibre in my corner.
    Mrs C
  • John came highly recommended to me …..from the start of my case to its conclusion John was sympathetic, resolute with your advice and kept me focused and grounded. I can’t thank him enough for what he has done for me.
    Mrs H